Research paper & manuscript review
Stress-test your research before submission.
Get structured feedback on your manuscript, challenge potential weaknesses and explore journal fit, so you can submit with greater confidence.
- Research Paper
- Journal Article
- Conference Paper
- Preprint
- Manuscript
- No credit card required
- PDF report
- Your work. Your decisions.
A more rigorous review of your research.
ScholarLens analyses your manuscript across eight key areas, highlighting strengths, potential weaknesses and areas to develop, with detailed, constructive feedback.
Originality
Ideas and contribution
Significance
Importance and relevance
Methodology
Approach and design
Evidence
Use and quality of evidence
Literature
Engagement with existing work
Logic
Structure and flow of argument
Clarity
Writing and presentation
Ethics
Ethical considerations
Go beyond a standard review.
Get a deeper, more critical analysis of your work with adversarial review, plus tailored journal recommendations.
- Standard reviewA comprehensive assessment across eight key dimensions, with detailed feedback and actionable suggestions.
- Adversarial reviewA more critical, reviewer-style analysis that challenges your arguments and identifies potential weaknesses.
- Journal matchingFind journals where your work fits, with acceptance insights and guidance on how to strengthen your submission.
Adversarial review
Review 1Central numerical claims are unverifiable without primary citation
These two numbers are the quantitative backbone of the paper's claims but are not traceable to a citable source. A reader cannot verify them, which undermines the credibility of the argument.
Required fix: Provide explicit citation for both figures or replace with a publicly available source.
Heisenberg limit claimed as achievable while QEC necessity unresolved
The paper presents GHZ-based metrology as complementary to QEC but does not resolve the tension between scaling advantage and error correction requirements.
Required fix: Add a dedicated discussion section addressing this tension with relevant citations.
Find journals where your work fits.
Get tailored journal recommendations based on your manuscript, with acceptance insights and guidance on how to improve your chances.
- Journals matched to your research area
- Acceptance probability estimates
- Impact factor and time to first decision
- Specific advice to strengthen your submission
Journal matchingExample
| # | Journal | Fit | Acceptance odds | Impact factor | Time to decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nature Physics | 72% | 72% | 38.1 | ~28 days |
| 2 | PRX Quantum | 85% | 85% | 5.5 | ~45 days |
| 3 | Physical Review Letters | 55% | 55% | 8.5 | ~42 days |
Make changes. Review again.
Track your progress with multiple reviews, so you can see exactly what's improved and what still needs attention.
Review 1
ScholarLens Rating
50 / 80
revisions
Review 2
ScholarLens Rating
55 / 80
The ScholarLens Rating is an assessment across ScholarLens review dimensions, not a predicted academic grade or classification.
A trusted companion on your research journey.
ScholarLens gives you an additional, independent perspective on your work, whenever you need it. It doesn't replace your supervisor, collaborators or peers — it helps you prepare, refine and strengthen your research.